PACTAby Fractal Neurons
Request a dossier

Protocol scorecards

Pinned blocks: Ethereum #26,440,048 · Base #58,956,515 · 27 Base EAS batches

Docs vs chain, a five-factor control-plane rosette and the main difference for each of 229 protocols. Select a row for the evidence.

38 of 229 protocols differ from their docs: 30 adverse, 8 protective.

Aligned means the docs are accurate, not that the protocol is low-risk.

Docs vs chain compares what a protocol publishes with what its contracts enforce at a finalized block. The rosette shows how strong the controls themselves are.

RosetteStrongModerateWeakNot determinedLonger, greener slices are stronger. Clockwise from the top: upgradeability, timelock floor, signer quorum, emergency scope, docs-vs-chain parity.

Protocol scorecards: docs-vs-chain status, five-factor control-plane rosette and the main difference for each protocol. Select a row to expand its evidence.
ProtocolDocs vs chainControl-plane rosetteWhat differsExpand
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAligned3Jane Lending's Upgrades admin acts through a 7-day timelock, as documented
BaseAlignedPause and unpause admin is the Aave Guardian 4-of-7 Safe, as documented
EthereumAlignedACL admin role, executor delay and Guardian Safe match the docs
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedOnly allow-listed proposers can submit root bundles, as documented
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed
BaseDeltaVoter emergency council and epoch governor are the AerodromeMigration contract
BaseAlignedPool factory owner and fee managers are the 3-of-7 team Safe, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 4-of-8 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 4-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 6-of-11 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 4-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaDeployment config lists an older gateway implementation; 3-day timelock with operator path
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedAuthorizer admin role is the 6-of-11 DAO multisig, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaDocs list an older restaking implementation; uniETH upgrades via a 3-of-5 Safe ProxyAdmin
BaseDeltaTimelock delay: docs 6 hours · chain none
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-6 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 5-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumProtectiveAccess-control admin is a Timelock, not the multisig the docs name
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
BaseAlignedOpsGuardian has no pause authority over Root, as documented
EthereumDeltaDocs: only the MCMS proposes · chain: a 6-of-12 Safe can also propose
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed
Base · EthereumAlignedUSDC roles on Base are single admin addresses, as Circle documents
EthereumAlignedThe exchange rate is set by a rate-limited updater, as documented
BaseAlignedBase markets follow the Ethereum Timelock plus a 1-day local timelock
EthereumAlignedGovernor, 48-hour Timelock and Pause Guardian Safe match the docs
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 6-of-9 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaVault and factory manager Safe runs at 1-of-2 despite documented role separation
EthereumAlignedBooster governance ownership chain matches the docs
EthereumAlignedThe Cooler Loans multisig is a 4-of-8 Safe, as its docs state
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedThe Curve DEX (Ethereum) multisig is a 5-of-9 Safe, as its docs state
EthereumDeltacrvUSD factory admin is a LendingOwnerProxy; docs name the OwnershipAgent
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedThe Eclipse Bridge multisig is a 3-of-5 Safe, as its docs state
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedCore ProxyAdmin, executor Safe and 10-day Timelock match the docs
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumProtectiveTimelock delay: docs none · chain 7 days (stricter)
EthereumAlignedEquilibria changes wait a 24-hour timelock, as documented
EthereumAlignedThe ETH Strategy multisig is a 3-of-5 Safe, as its docs state
EthereumDeltaTimelock delay: docs 7 days · chain 1 day
EthereumProtectiveUSDtb PSM is owned by a 24-hour timelock, not the Dev multisig directly
EthereumProtective10-day upgrade timelock; a queued LayerZero delegate change moves behind it
EthereumAlignedRolesAuthority owner and timelock wiring match the docs
EthereumAlignedFactory upgrades wait 4 days in a timelock (DAO 4-of-8 proposes), as documented
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
BaseObservedNon-proxy lending pool with role-based admin; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaTreasury admin sits with the Ops and Emergency Safes, not the 3-day Timelock
EthereumAlignedsUSDf cooldown is zero, so unstaking to USDf is instant, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaMigration auth is live on four vaults, beyond the documented multisig scope
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedfrxETHMinter owner is the documented Comptroller
EthereumAlignedUpgrades go through a 1-day timelock run by the 4-of-7 Frax Safe
EthereumDeltaTimelock delay: docs 2 days · chain 36 hours
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedThe Gravity by Galxe Bridge multisig is a 3-of-6 Safe, as its docs state
EthereumAlignedAllocator custody role admin is the Grove SubProxy under Sky governance
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
BaseObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaPause roles are administered by MINOR_ROLES_MANAGER; docs say GOVERNOR
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaPolicy Committee Safe: docs 5-of-9 · chain 4-of-7
BaseAlignedThe IPOR Fusion ERC1967Proxy is upgradeable (UUPS), as its docs state
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedProxyAdmin sits behind a 10-day timelock; config admin Safe as documented
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedThe KUMA Protocol multisig is a 4-of-7 Safe, as its docs state
EthereumAlignedEndpoint is immutable; a 5-of-9 multisig sets the message defaults, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedDual Governance timelock delays and committee Safes match the docs
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedUpgrade and admin firewalls are run by 4-of-7 Safes, as documented
EthereumAlignedLiquidation thresholds are 110% and 150% in Recovery Mode, as documented
EthereumAlignedSampled owner and proxy slots match the docs
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedCore ProxyAdmin wiring and 24-hour timelock match the docs
EthereumAlignedMToken has no proxy slots: immutable core logic, as documented
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumProtectiveTimelock delay: docs none · chain 3 days (stricter)
EthereumDeltaProxy admin is the 4-of-7 DAO Safe; docs describe a 3-day GovernorTimelock
EthereumDeltaCurator Safe: docs 3-of-6 · chain 3-of-5
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-6 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaRe7 WETH vault has no guardian; its owner is a 2-of-4 Safe with a 3-day timelock
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
BaseDeltaPause guardian: docs 3-of-5 Security Council · chain 2-of-4 Safe
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 5-of-9 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedSingleton owner and fee and LLTV bounds match the docs
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedGovernance needs 3 Advisory Board votes plus a 24-hour timelock, as documented
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaSupply: docs cap 500M · chain no cap; a 2-of-3 Safe holds the minter role
EthereumDeltaOUSG instant mint limit: docs $50M · chain $100M per day
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed
BaseObservedVault proxy admin path runs through a 2-day timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-7 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedPause and asset-protection roles sit with one key address, as documented
EthereumAlignedMarkets send 80% of swap fees to the treasury and 20% to LPs, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-6 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedThe Polygon Bridge multisig is a 5-of-9 Safe, as its docs state
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedThe Privacy Pools V1 PoolVault proxy is upgradeable (UUPS), as its docs state
EthereumDeltaCommunity multisig: docs 3-of-6 · chain 3-of-7
EthereumAligned0.25% shield fees; upgrades and pauses only via the on-chain protocol vote, as documented
EthereumProtectiveVault admin role sits only behind the timelock; docs say the Safe holds it too
EthereumDeltaRestaking fee: docs 10% · chain 15%
EthereumAlignedLong freeze is 1 week, the documented default
EthereumAlignedUSR admin-rules delay and request counters match the docs
EthereumDeltaSafe threshold: docs 3-of-4 · chain 3-of-5
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaCouncil leave notice: chain 28 days · RPIP-33 bound under 14 days
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedv1.4.1 singleton and factory code match Safe's registry; singletons cannot be initialized
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
BaseObservedNon-proxy address provider with role-based admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
EthereumProtectiveBeacon upgrades already wait 3 days in a timelock the docs say will be added
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed
BaseObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedAddresses provider owner and governance delay match the docs
BaseObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedSSVNetwork owner is the DAO governance multisig, as documented
EthereumDeltaManager Safe: docs 3-of-5 · chain 3-of-6
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaTimelock: docs 2 days · chain 5 days; Treasury Safe 3-of-5, not 4-of-7
EthereumAlignedGovernance timelock delay is 48 hours, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedKeeper oracle quorum, osETH fee and LTV settings match the docs
EthereumAlignedPools and treasurer are owned by a 5-of-7 multisig, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedsteakUSDC guardian is its own Aragon DAO, as announced
BaseAlignedMetaMorpho vault timelock is 7 days, as documented
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 2-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
BaseObservedSuperGovernor and vault aggregator control plane pinned; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedUSDC subscription fee and fund supply match the docs
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
EthereumAligned7-day SwellTimelock, ProxyAdmins and reprice bounds match the docs
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedCore registries are non-upgradeable; factory Safes match the docs
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedAccount NFT is owned by the CoreProxy, not a key or Safe, as documented
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 2-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedOwner is a 3-of-6 MultiSigWallet, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a timelock; docs not assessed
EthereumAlignedtBTC timelock is 1 day; the WalletRegistry upgrade schedule is public
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaA 5-of-7 Safe can freeze TREE transfers at once; docs promise a 5-day timelock
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
BaseAlignedUmia changes wait a 2-day timelock, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a single key (EOA); docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaVoting period: docs 7 days · chain 5.6 days
Base · EthereumAlignedOwner is the 2-day governance Timelock run by GovernorBravo, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaTimelock delay: docs 3 days · chain 1 second
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-6 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-8 Safe; docs not assessed
Base · EthereumAlignedMessages and upgrades need 13 of 19 guardians on Ethereum and Base, as documented
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 3-of-5 Safe; docs not assessed
BaseObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a 3-of-4 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumProtectiveTimelock delay: docs none · chain 7 days (stricter)
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumDeltaDocs state a 2-of-3 YNDelegator; the YieldNest Safe is 2-of-4
BaseDeltaTimelock delay: docs 2 days · chain none
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a 2-of-3 Safe; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedNon-proxy contract controlled by a contract; docs not assessed
BaseObservedNon-proxy contract no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed
EthereumObservedUpgradeable proxy no readable owner or admin; docs not assessed